The Debut

The Debut, 2026, 4 stars

Stage fright

Moore is terrified, and terrifying, as theatrical newbie

Julianne Moore stars in The Debut. (Image is copyright A24.)

Exclusive to MeierMovies, November 19, 2026

Mona Friedman is a nobody. Ignored by her husband and forgotten by her kids, she is more housecleaner than housewife, more maid than mom. She’s the pet dog left tied up to a tree outside the fancy restaurant while the humans are inside enjoying life.

So when she gets the chance to audition for a small but pivotal part in a musical at the local theatre, Mona takes an unlikely leap from home to stage, from shadow to limelight.

Guiding her through this new life is the show’s director, Jerry Blankenbuehler, who seems alternatingly bullying and kind, intimidating and nurturing, confident and vulnerable – depending upon which mask he’s wearing at a given time.

But Mona’s masks, it turns out, are more terrifying than she, Jerry or anyone else had realized. Even more frightening, though, is what’s under the mask and just how far the scared bunny will go in pursuit of her inner killer rabbit once she gets a small taste of fame.

Under Jesse Eisenberg’s direction, however, The Debut is not a frightening film. It’s unsettling, challenging, occasionally tonally challenged and often wickedly funny, but it’s not anything close to, say, Daren Aronofsky’s Black Swan, with which it shares some themes. Instead, it’s stuck between that psychological horror and Christopher Guest’s Waiting for Guffman, with a dash of A Star Is Born. It’s not always on point and the plot isn’t entirely credible, but it’s never ordinary.

In addition to helming, Eisenberg co-produced the film and has a small part, in which he briefly sings and dances. He also wrote the songs for the musical-within-the-movie, Nosy Neighbors. And in one of the great marketing moves of recent years, attendees of early screenings were given fake Playbill programs for that show, complete with bios of Mona, Jerry and the other “actors,” with the Playbill bearing the name of New Jersey’s Brook Arts Center, a real theatre where the fake play and the real film are set. Talk about metatheatricality.

Despite Eisenberg wearing more hats than a hydra milliner, the film owes just as much of its aesthetic success to two of the year’s best performances: Julianne Moore as Mona and Paul Giamatti as Jerry. They are near-locks for Oscar nominations for lead actress and supporting actor, respectively, as they successfully embrace Eisenberg’s dramatic yet often fantastical and slightly surreal vision. Halle Bailey (another actor in the musical) and Patrick Fabian (Mona’s husband) offer pitch-perfect support, as does another performer (in the year’s best cameo) who will go unnamed here. The result is 2026’s oddest, most stylistic depiction of life imitating art – after Digger, that is.

“You’re aiming for gorgeous, but I’m aiming for reality,” Mona tells Jerry as she starts to lose her own reality. The film’s central question, however, concerns not Mona’s masks but our own – and how, when and why we wear them.

The Debut also shines a spotlight on the delusions and pretensions of the theatre, and all art, and how quickly one can go from nobody to “artist.” But unfortunately for the cast and crew of Nosy Neighbors – as in the aforementioned Guest film – Guffman isn’t coming. He’s snowed under.

© 2026 MeierMovies, LLC

For more information on the movie, visit IMDB and Wikipedia. The film is currently playing festivals and is scheduled for a wide release in the United States on December 11. It is rated R.